I think Kip should dump them both! Which one of the girls has the dignity to say to Kip “if you love her more than me and she makes you happier, then go and have a great life together”.
Kip is the college quarterback who just won the game with two seconds left. He has to have girls in his face no matter where he goes, and Stef should be well aware of it. Tiffany should take the high road and wait until Kip and Stef breakup.
Having watched many, many sporting events, I have sometimes noticed the cheerleaders (male and female) are in better physical shape than the athletes plying in the actual game.
Life’s last lesson is the hardest one to accept for most people.